Piobaireachd
This is a huge topic and no longer belongs to the realm of beginner 'piping.
It
is also an immensely satisfying topic and after entering the world of
piobaireachd for real, many see a whole new galaxy of 'piping.
Piobaireachd (also pibroch), also known as ceol mor
('the great music'), is often called the classical music of the 'pipes,
and it is without doubt a genre which places the great highland bagpipe
in a different world to the rest of the world's bagpipe traditions.
This form is unique in the bagpipe world to the Scottish tradition.
What is it?
A theme and variations essentially in the Baroque fashion.
The theme is called the 'Ground'
and the variations are stylised. The variations take the essential
underlying structure of the ground and subject this structure to
systematic actions, variations. These variations have names. They are often given
twice each, the second of which has an additional change in the same
general direction the the first. These are called Singlings and
Doublings.
The ground is made up of a series of musical motifs, which can be thought about and worked with as rhetorical figures.
Traditionally,
ceol mor is notated using a system of words called 'canntaireachd'.
Historically, there are two systems, one of which is in common use
today. Canntaireachd influences timing and understanding of phrasing.
How does piobaireachd function musically?
- The
drones provide a musical space and harmonic background. They should be
set up and tuned in a way that accents and highlights the upper
partials (harmonics) in the sound spectrum, and this gives a fullness
and richness against which the chanter notes 'sing' and create harmonic
tensions.
- The rise and fall of these tensions creates one plane in which ceol mor functions musically.
- The
next plane is is terms of melodic tension. This tension is created
through the intervals from note to note and the cumulative effect of
all of this tension in each phrase.
- A third plane of musical function is in the relationship between the ground and the variations.
- And
then...there is the physical space in which we perform. The acoustics
of the room or open air environment change the way in which we hear the
harmonics, and the build up and release of tension, and so alter the
way we play.
How do we listen to it?
- We mentally turn off time.
- Each note should be heard against the drones.
- Each note should be heard against what comes before and what comes next.
- Allow the whole effect to engulf us.
How do we understand its interpretation?
There
are two broad definitions to consider here - 'expressionist' and
'classical'. These are not traditional terms, but terms proposed here
by the writer.
Classical
means we aim to create an interpretation according to a school of
thought and tradition and concentrate on highlighting musical rhetorics
at play. We impose an interpretation on the environment.
Expressionist
means we react to the playing circumstances more than classical
interpretation and we thus have greater irregularity of pace and pulse
and phrase crafting.
Keeping these points in mind, then listen as above and generate interpretations according to the ideas above.
What are the specific challenges?
- Rhythm and pulse are questions which are less regular than 'functional' pipe music (marches and dances).
- The contrast in length between notes and gracenotes is huge. This brings its own special challenges.
- There
are many areas where we need to have a mental sub-division of pulses of
2, 3 and 4 units, and also situations where pulses themselves are
grouped into complex compunded arrays of triplets and other
irregularities at the same time. The writer is working on midi
programming the computer to play interpretations of grounds in order to
further identify what these patterns and complexities are. This is a
research project and is revealing insights to interpretation which
considerably simplify the process of understanding how to play a given
piece, which is why a few midi interpretations are included on this site
- Keeping
the instrument in tune for a long time...Pieces of ceol mor last from 3
minutes to 30 minutes...That is a long time to blow and stay in tune.
- Memorising tunes.
- General stamina - mental and physical.
Why do we have piobaireachd?
As
with other pieces of pipe music, important occasions in the history of a
Clan or other group were marked by composing a piece of ceol mor. This
is why we have Laments, Salutes, Battle tunes and other incidental
tales. As time has gone by and social context has changed, we have
expanded what might be commemorated by a composition and who, and
linked the musical content more exactly to the meta-musical layer (the
title and the story). In historical music, the titles may not always
match the content, so care should be taken.
Other comments...
This
is a massive field and people become students of piobaireachd for their
whole lives. It is a matter that rouses great passions, and thus
controversy. Sensitivity to other viewpoints is advised, and a pinch of
salt is recommended. A good guiding principle is to check the internal
musical arguments presented whenever someone presents a position that
seems a bit dogmatic.
There are movements for historical
performance style and for further embedding the competition style. New
compositions are appearing.
For details on playing all the words which appear in canntaireachd, in
due course there will links form the canntaireachd page to each
embellishment or musical figure.
Books the serious student of ceol mor will want in due course:
- Kilberry book - the starting point for the 100 tunes. There are follow up books called 'sidelights'.
- The Piobaireachd Society books - a long series with more detailed remarks about the tunes. 360 plus pieces.
Qualifying remark
Understanding ceol mor was a significant part of the writer's (Lindsay Davidson) doctoral research in the field of music.
'Expressionist' and 'classical' are the writer's viewpoints and proposals.
This section is making progress...August 2025.
As this is a large project, please add to your favourites and keep coming back.