How to Practise
Franz Liszt was said to be the
greatest pianist ever. He had a
method of practising, which we can use for 'piping. By adding a few
extra steps
we can develop individual high performance methods. The more effective
one's
practise, the faster one learns and the greater the motivation.
This page is where you will find
some secrets of how to be a
better 'piper.
Truthfully,
we can see learning bagpipes as a philosophy and schema for successful
learning in al domains of life, if you want to.
Please note
Many issues arise during
individual practice for which there
are often quick and simple answers. Please get
in touch to ask about your particular problem.
Not every single issue can be
predicted, nor can this list of
suggestions ever be complete.
Finding the magic explanation
which helps the student grasp
what they are seeking is the art of teaching. What to say often depends
on when
it is to be said and to whom. For this, unfortunately, a teach yourself method will
never
suffice.
Preamble...
When we experience something, the
brain makes connections
between neurons. These connections are either reinforced by being
refreshed, or
replaced with new but very similar patterns. When we play something
nearly
correctly, in fact what we do is create a new set of competing
connections between
neurons which then need to be dismissed when playing next time. We can
liken this
to making a map and drawing new junctions every time we make a mistake.
If we
don't delete the mistakes, we will soon be unable to use the map, and get lost...
Changing our mistakes, mentally
comparing the thing we played
with that which we aimed at playing or wanted to play, will make our
learning
much more effective and efficient.
By breaking playing down into its
smallest elements, we can
perfect every small element and then (re)assemble these elements to
make strong
'pipers. We can think of this as learning rudiments
and then
putting them into practise.
Finger control
When just starting to play, the
fingers are not very well
disciplined and don't necessarily respond correctly to instructions.
Often
instructions to move a finger on the left hand will be sent to the
right hand, and vice versa.
This is a cyclical problem - as we break through different stages of
development,
the hands decide for themselves that they know better and then the 'lefts
and rights'
problem (re)appears.
There is a simple exercise for this.
- Place your
hands flat on the table
- Raise your
index and ring fingers together, wthout moving any other fingers
- Moving all four
fingers at once, put down your index and ring fingers and raise instead
your little finger (pinky) and middle finger.
- Repeat quickly,
with your eyes closed, with hands crossed over, with hands following
alternate positions (ring finger up in left hand, down in right etc),
move in various rhythms and so on.
|
Please note, thumbs are not used
in this exercise, and this is
something which will need to be repeated frequently. To begin with it
will be
terrible, but the hands will learn amazingly quickly.
Doing this at the
beginning will give as much progress as all other practise.
'Good' Technique
Good technique is the ability to
control one's fingers, to
make them do what one wants them to do when one wants it done. It is
not playing fancy things very quickly.
Good technique must be combined
with musical understanding to
decide when things will be done, to know exactly the rhythm of each and
every
gracenote, why it should be thus, and how to make it happen.
Advanced
There is no such thing as more or less difficult in 'piping – only more or less intense….
Stepping
up to an intermediate/advanced level of 'piping should be a challenge. A
new tune at a new new level should take some work and you should feel
mentally tired, but not de-motivated.
How does one eat an elephant?
Not in one bite, and not all in one session.
Just the same is true for pushing your 'piping to a higher level.
It
is also important that when you start to learn new material, and push
to a new level, the first few tunes you do will be ‘disposable’, that
is, there will be mistakes caused by stretching your technique. Do not
waste effort going back over the same things for years – simply learn a
new tune and concentrate on fixing that which has gone wrong. That is,
do not try and drag your technique to a higher level using your
favourite tunes, as you will end up either being put off them, or
spending an immense amount of time needlessly unprogramming the process
of getting better from your hands later (rather than enjoying the result of having got better).
The 'Piping
Muscle
There is such a thing! Like
building any muscle, one should
work away until the muscle fails (everything goes wrong) and then rest
and allow
it to recover. Identifying when finger control has gone beyond mental
capacity is
an art for teachers to master, and is important as a change in tactics
will be
needed to develop mental capacity for 'piping to keep a student
motivated.
Teaching yourself, you must know that there is such a thing as a 'piping
muscle
and that you need to keep tiring it, from one or another angle, but let
it
recover too.
Exact method
Playing any and all instruments are pretty
well based on the same
principles; moving the fingers up and down in a certain order
in a certain
time - the order is technique and the time (rhythm) is music. By
corrupting the
time we make personal musical interpretations.
Thus, technique can be programmed and
guaranteed
like programming a computer. Like with a computer actions are very
close
together in time but not simultaneous. By doing this programming
effectively, we
can guarantee our technique and use the spare energy on controlling our
individual musical expression.
Liszt played one note, seven
times in a row corectly, and when
he had achieved this, he added the next note and started again at the beginning, and so on until the
entire piece
was done.
There are five stages in learning
to play something:
- Basic
programming of fingers
(each instructional page on the site shows a diagram of X+O for the
order of open and closed holes on the chanter, meaning fingers up or
down). X means holes closed/finger down and O means hole open/finger up.
- Grouping the
instructions.
Think of jumping from one place to another...you can only plan the
jumps when you are on the ground, and it is the same with your finger
actions - don't stop in the middle of a gracenote....but plan from
before opening the gracenote until closing it.
- Assigning time
markers
(beats and smaller units) to the groups of instructions. This means you
have an idea that a finger will open or close on the beat, or if not on
the beat...where else it will move.
- Making the time
(tempo) even, steady. Steadiness is key, not speed. Super, super slow is fine. You can use the visual metronome for this.
- Speeding up. Slowly and steadily increase the speed, again a metronome can help.
|
Each and every step should be
practised seven times in a row
correctly. This is very hard at the beginning but gets easier with time.
The
early stages of learning with this method seem to take forever, but the
result
is vastly accelerated learning later on.
Band/Group
Learning
Any individual in a group can
have a problem at any one of the
steps outlined above. Often, just pulling a band all back to basic
programming
in a small problem area will solve the problem, and can often be highly
motivational - everyone can discover an area they were weak on.
The teacher has the
responsibility to quickly and discreetly
identify exactly who has a problem with which step, and either tell
that person
individually what is going wrong, or find a collective exercise which
can avoid
embarrasment, but solve the targeted issue.
A band is only as strong as its
weakest player. Periodically
the leader/teacher should individually assess each member and generate
individual exercises for that person to solve their biggest challenges
whilst at
the same time finding exercises which can benefit the whole group.
Choice of
repertoire should have two goals - to highlight a group's strengths,
but also to
develop (improve) areas of weakness.
Every rehearsal should feel like
a lesson for every individual.
Every time a tune is played, someone in the group should be given
something to
improve, preferablly two or three people. Everyone should get the same
number of
elements to improve in an evening so that no-one feels either too good,
or
picked on/singled out. This way, a fairly wide range of playing accomplishment and experience can
be served
in one group (within reason).
A good band plays the same thing
at the same time using the
same techniques. In the 'good old days', 'grunt and slap' was a norm in
teaching,
especially in pipe bands. That is, the pipe major would growl 'not this
way, not
that way, but something else', then play something similar, and call it
a lesson.
The student would firstly be expected to not ask for an explanation, and secondly, to copy
like a
monkey.
The above method does
away with the need to be
perpetually negative in a lesson. It is possible to examine more
carefully what
a student is playing, and test it against what is being aimed for. This
allows
us to establish positive goals, and identify which tools we need, and
what we
don't have, in order to achieve our goals.
The magic maxim
goes thus:
"If you can play slowly,
you can play
quickly, but the
converse isn't necessarily true"
In 'piping at the highest level,
you will need to be able to
decide minutiae of when to open and close every single gracenote, and
exactly
how much time to give to it. To program this exactly, you will need to
be able
to play very slowly indeed, and bluffing will not be possible.
Using playback files/videos at different speeds
The magic maxim means exactly what it says - the
better you become the more exactly you should be able to control what you are
doing, and so to test ourselves, we shouldn't practice more quickly, but more
slowly.
To think again like computers - a sampling
rate for a recording is a measure of how many times a second the computer will
measure what is happening in the sound. A higher sampling rate makes for a
higher quality of recording, up to a point beyond which it doesn't make much
difference. It is the same with 'piping - the more times in a beat you can say
exactly what is happening, the better your 'piping, up to a point..
This also gives you more capacity to manage your performance when unexpected things happen.
By remembering the five steps in learning, we can see that at the
point when we assign time to our actions we can get better by increasing our
sampling rate. We do this simply by dividing by two, and playing at half speed,
with awareness of twice as many points in the beat. When we succeed at this
level, we half our speed again, and double the number of places in the bar we
try to feel and be aware of what is happening. We keep doing this until every
gracenote can be measured opening and closing. If you know the 'New French Method'
of rhythm, this helps dramatically, as it automatically gives us a sampling rate
of four points per beat by saying the word 'tafatifi' all the time in our heads.
And if we say the same word on each of these sub-beats...we have 16
times more accuracy in our playing, than if we just aim for the sound
we hear from others.
To use the playback videos and files, start with a quick
one (or a medium one) and when you feel you are playing with this nicely, go to
a slower one, and try to feel more detail. First listen carefully, bearing in
mind that most things are divided by two, to find where the actions occur.
Obviously, when you accomplish this, go to the next slower file.
Once you have gone to the slowest file and
played along correctly, start to go through the faster ones again to see how
much more precisely you are playing, and hearing what you are playing.
Playing exactly with the playback files at a
quarter speed is a fairly good test for a group, and this extra secret can
dramatically affect the strength of playing within a band, and the confidence.
It is true that using this approach, you can bring about a positive revolution
in your band's playing and attitude.
If you know the New French Method, great.
If not, you will need to' feel' the rhythm (until we can figure out how to
explain the method via internet...).
Please note, that between X+O, the five
steps and practising more slowly and increasing your sampling rate, all with
seven repetitions, you can genuinely guarantee your band can play technically
perfectly. It can be mind-numbingly difficult and very challenging, but
remember, no-one wants to be the person do make the mistake on repetition
six...especially at low speed.
It's a simple set of tasks, the trick is in
disciplining yourself to do it.