The
Gordon's Salute is an excellent piobaireachd for helping a non-'piping
audience access this style of music because the structure is
exceptionally clear and lends itself to being drawn out and exposed.
Each
variation will be discussed here separately, and a video with the
complete music to play along with is at the end (high pitch and low
pitch).
The full music, notated mostly conventionally:
Where
there is a 'T' or a 'C' written under the note, this means play a high
G gracenote to the note and if 'T' then you play a taorluath to low A,
and if 'C' then you play a crunluath to E.
This is a very helpful convention and saves lots of ink and paper. You play the Taorluath variation first, then the crunluath.
This
abbreviation also means you can see the essential harmonic and melodic
structure. It is always good to learn piobaireachd from these variations
to the beginning, noting where the Ground and last variations deviate
from each other.
Canntaireachd
It
is very wise to learn the canntaireachd words for each piobaireachd you
study and learn how to sing the tune whilst you get the technical
elements and general understanding in place.
The canntaireachd
reveals that the Es which are so common here are to be thought about as
cadence notes, so not main beat notes, but a kind of auxiliary note.
It
is suggesed to listen to the video and sing a long with it, paying
attention to where you need to breathe and where you feel you should
get louder or quieter. This natural rise and fall in your singing will
contribute to your sense of connection with your interpration and help
build greater sense into it.
Singing a hundred times before you even touch the chanter is OK!
Ground/Urlar
Line 1 Hiharin hihodarodo, hiharin hihodrodin, hiemdan hihiotrodin
Line 2 Hihodarodo hihodrodin, hiemdan hihiodro, hiemdan hihiotrodin
Line 3 Hihodarodo hihodrodin, hiemdan hihiotrodin.
The actual rhythm...
The
true challenge of performing piobaireachd is reproducing the effects that
can be produced by singing and taking breaths to come across
effectively with a continuous sound and gracenotes to give accents.
This leads to a tremendously complex rhythmical reality.
It
is possible (but extremely complex) to notate every single finger
movement and its timing in staff notation, and this can be tested and
proofed by asking a computer to play the result. Doing this is an
extremely helpful exercise as it reveals exactly where the
irregularities are and how to comprehend them and overcome them so that
the melody can be adequately presented. The full in-depth notation...is
essentially impossible to usefully read as it involves rhythmical
contrast ranging from whole notes to 1/1024th notes and triplets inside
triplets too..
Here is a presentation of a half way house - showing
the big rhythmical questions, something we could call the 'active' elements, but leaving some things as gracenotes for
clarity.
.
Discussion points about the Ground/Urlar
It isn't 4/4...
1
The opening birl - the D gracenote is before the point of emphasis
(aka.. the 'beat') and the low A should 'ripple' on and after the beat.
2 The cadential Es are typically in triplets and are opened before the beat.
3
The darodo/bubbly note - the D and C gracenotes are very strong and add an
extra event. Give them accent in your singing and try to do the same in
the 'piping. The text should almost be bold and underlined and in big
letters...
4 The grips are actually quite light in effect, so
should be sung (and played) without rolling the 'R' in the 'dro' and
'tro' too much.
5 The end of bar 2 reveals a true oddity -
the 'din' (low G gracenote to low A) shows that the low A is off beat
and 'late'. This rhythmical indirectness leads to a softening of the
beat, such that it lessens the effect of ending and allows the whole
ground to be phrased as one big long phrase (this also makes
piobaireachd much harder to manage interpretatively, given the
concentration needed).
6 The triplet with the grips is also a way of reducing the drive and increasing the grandiosity of the music.
7
Bar 3, low G to low A - this is not a triplet, but addition of
extra 8th notes in the bar. This makes for a tremendous subtletly in
rhythm, one of the complexities of piobaireachd. You need to explore
ways of counting this that make sense to you, and listen with awareness
to the recording.
8 It is considered good conventional practice to slow down towards the end of the Ground.
Discussion points about the Dithis
1 The high G gracenotes are twice as long as the E gracenotes, consistently.
2 Mark the rhythm in the proportion 3:1 as is indicated in the notation. This gives a spritely and bright effect.
3
It is considered good practice to slow down in the last bar of
the singling and then hit a new tempo, slightly higher than the
singling, for the doubling, and again, slow down at the end of the
variation going into the taorluath. Discussion points about the Taorluath
1
Be aware that the actual tempo is minimally slower than the Dithis, but
as there are more gracenotes...the effect is that it is more intense
and seems, in a way, to be faster.
2 The high G gracenotes are the same size/length as in the dithis - quite big.
3 The proportions are theme note:taorluath:Low A = 2:1:1 (8th note:16th:16th) see coloured boxes below.
4 As
above, it is considered good practice to slow down slightly at the end
of the variation to indicate the next variation is coming.
theme note
taorluath
low A
2
1
1
Discussion points about the Crunluath
1
This actually takes place in 12/8, not 4/4, but is traditionally
notated in 4/4 as the gracenote timings are never written down. 2
Think of the crunluath having 'active' and 'passive' elements.
'Active' means the things we would write down by ear - the Low Gs and
low As in the embellishment. Passive are the cutting notes, which have
definite pitch but are so short a normal person wouldn't be able to
write them down from hearing. The effect of the active elements is that
they seem to all be of the same length. The passive ones should be
small enough to not interfere with the rippling effect. The desired
rhythmical effect is illustrated below. Please be aware there is
another way of playing a crunluath, with sloightly longer low Gs. Both
are valid and recognised.
3 Please note that in effect, the destination E in a crunluath is syncopated.
4
Listen carefully with this information in mind and you will be
able to hear the rhythm coming across in the lows G and low As
5
As with other variations, you should slow down at the end of
this variation, more than the other variations as this is showing the
end of the variations and return to the ground. This is a matter of
musical semiotics.
'Active' elements...
It
is conventional to repeat the Ground for piobaireachd after you have
played all the variations. For longer pieces in public performance, the
'piper often only repeats the first line. For small pieces like this and
for private satisfaction, repeating the whole Ground is a good idea.
It is common to add a crunuath a mach variation in this tune, and especially effective for concert performance.
Once
you have thought about all of these things, you can sing and play along
with the videos below. These videos are made from the notation and are
played by the computer as a demonstration that this approach is
possible and actually works.
The Gordon's Salute from midi - whole tune low pitch
The Gordon's Salute from midi - whole tune high pitch